What happens when a reliable man decides to become unreliable? Should he be held to account? Who’s to say?
The Man Who Wasn’t There (2001) is finally getting its day in court, entering the Criterion Collection on February 24th, 2026. It is an overlooked film in the titanic oeuvre of the Coen Brothers. On its release, the populace, shaken by the recent events of 9/11, was as unprepared for its brilliance as the children of the ‘30s and ‘40s were for the post-War fortunes heaped upon them. With this new release, Ed Crane (Billy Bob Thornton) and Freddy Riedenschneider (Tony Shalhoub) make the case for two of the great American film performances in one of the Coen Brother’s top 5 films, and what should be in every conversation for Maestro Roger Deakin’s (No Country for Old Men) best work. It is certainly his most pristine.
“What kind of man are you?”
Ed Crane is a barber. He’s thinking about getting into dry cleaning instead. He’s played by Billy Bob Thornton (Landman; Slingblade). Ed is married to Doris Crane. She’s played by Frances McDormand (Fargo; The French Dispatch). She’s married to director Joel Coen (The Tragedy of Macbeth; Fargo).
Billy Bob Thornton as Ed in THE MAN WHO WASN’T THERE. Photo courtesy of The Criterion Collection.
This is not a movie about their marriage, and it’s not nice to speculate. This is a movie about getting into dry cleaning. And Ed and Doris’s marriage.
Doris is fucking Big Dave. He’s played by James Gandolfini (The Sopranos; Where the Wild Things Are). They think Ed doesn’t know. Ed knows. They think he cares. He doesn’t think he does.
After a tragedy, Doris needs a lawyer. Ed rents her the best. His name is Freddy Riedenschneider. He is the best. He’s played by Tony Shalhoub (Monk; Ed Wood). He’s also the best. I’m certain about that. Freddy Riedenschneider says you can never be certain about anything.
Big Dave is fucking Doris. He is also the only person Ed lets touch his knee and get away with it. Is Ed gay? Director Ethan Coen (Honey, Don’t; Drive-Away Dolls) says on the director’s commentary that he doesn’t think so. He’s married to writer/director Tricia Cooke (Drive-Away Dolls; Honey, Don’t). She is also in a committed lesbian relationship.
This is not a film about their marriage, and it’s not nice to speculate. This is a movie about judgement. And being uncertain. And hair. Hair is life and death repeated above our brow. It also belongs in the dirt.
“What kind of man? Are you?”
No Country for Old Men (2007) is a film that takes place in the dirt. It remains the most celebrated film by The Coen Brothers and, in adaptation, they removed the narration of the novel in favor of naturalism. In The Man Who Wasn’t There, we rarely take a break from Ed Crane’s unnatural, matter-of-fact narration.
Spoilers for the ending of No Country for Old Men and The Man Who Wasn’t There.
Frances McDormand as Doris in THE MAN WHO WASN’T THERE. Photo courtesy of The Criterion Collection.
The Man Who Wasn’t There’s thematic engine revolves around a monologue by Shalhoub about the uncertainty principle which the Coens refer to as “silly nonsense.” It’s a monologue that infects the minds of the audience, as well as Ed Crane. It might be my favorite dialogue in their films. It’s in a tight horse race with the end of No Country, a passage by Cormac McCarthy (The Road; No Country for Old Men). They adapted it six years after the release of their own words about certainty and the afterlife spoken in a southern drawl:
“I don’t know where I’m being taken … I don’t know what waits for me, beyond the earth and sky. But I’m not afraid to go … Maybe the things I don’t understand will be clearer there, like when a fog blows away …. Maybe Doris will be there … And maybe there I can tell her … all those things … they don’t have words for here.”
– Billy Bob Thornton as Ed Crane, The Man Who Wasn’t There.
A tale of two Eds: Ed Crane and No Country’s Sheriff Ed Bell have both awoken from dreams where someone beckoned to them, then went on ahead. Ed Crane saw a UFO piloted by aliens that emasculated and violated Big Dave, a course he followed. Ed Bell saw his father, a sheriff whose protecting shoes he strove to fill. Ed Crane is abandoned to his chair, left wondering if the one he loves will be there. Ed Bell knows they will be.
“And in the dream I knew that he was goin’ on ahead and he was fixin’ to make a fire somewhere out there in all that dark and all that cold, and I knew that whenever I got there he would be there. And then I woke up …”
-Tommy Lee Jones as Sheriff Ed Bell, No Country for Old Men.
The Man Who Wasn’t There is as interested in the certainty of life and death as No Country for Old Men. It is as seriously assembled, as brilliantly shot, and as brilliantly acted. But it is not given the respect it deserves. A fitting life for a film about a man who is not respected by other men the way he thinks he ought to be. Revisited in 2026 in the wake of each Coen’s independent endeavors, perhaps that will change. It certainly seems more personal to their thoughts on death and marriage than it did 25 years ago.
A Serious Man (2009) is their most personal film about their identities. But The Man Who Wasn’t There might be their most personal film about the choices they have made as individuals. One of them is certainly obsessed with death and has considered what it means to be married to Francis McDormand, who here plays a Francis McDormand type. Another has certainly interrogated the queer and straight relationships to fidelity. Or maybe it’s just a gag like they say it is.
Freddy Riedenschneider would say that you can’t be certain, so you can’t render a verdict. Maybe this is why audiences seemed lukewarm to his tour-de-force performance, which grabs the proscenium by the collar and screams “THIS. IS. PERFORMANCE!”
Ed Crane might be the best thing Billy Bob Thorton ever did, but I’m not sure. I know him mostly from his phoned-in work on the pilot of Landman (2024 – ), which I was forced at gunpoint to watch. It’s strange that the man who has taken Costner’s (Horizon: An American Saga) place as the vehicle for Gen X’s paternalistic, misogynistic judgment of America was once capable of such a nuanced, posture-forward performance as Ed Crane, the very kind of vapid ignoramus who sees The Landman as finally telling the damn truth about things.
Scarlett Johansson as Birdy Abundas in THE MAN WHO WASN’T THERE. Photo courtesy of The Criterion Collection.
What is the truth? Is there truth? Should you purchase the Blu-ray or the 4K? Does it matter? Steve Yedlin says it doesn’t, but who’s the critic here? I am. But so is everybody. And everybody has been sleeping on The Man Who Wasn’t There and its all-American star: Ed Crane.
Is he gay? Is he the Modern Man? Is he autistic? Is he stupid? Is he lying? Depends on how you look at it. But it’s not nice to speculate.
The Man Who Wasn’t There 4K UHD Special Features:
- *NEW* 4K digital restoration, supervised and approved by director of photography Roger Deakins, with 5.0 surround DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack
- One 4K UHD disc of the film presented in Dolby Vision HDR and one Blu-ray with the film and special features
- Audio commentary featuring filmmakers Joel and Ethan Coen and actor Billy Bob Thornton
- *NEW* conversation between the Coens and author Megan Abbott
- Archival interview with Deakins
- Short making-of documentary and deleted scenes
- English subtitles for the deaf and hard of hearing
- PLUS: An essay by author Laura Lippman
- *NEW* cover by Marc Aspinall
Available on 4K UHD and Blu-ray February 24th, 2026.
For more information, head to the official The Criterion Collection The Man Who Wasn’t There webpage.
Share this:
Categories: Films To Watch, Home Release, Recommendation
Leave a Reply